EN
Home / Guides / Which Buck Island

Which Buck Island

One Buck Island has a marked underwater trail off St. Croix, the other is a turtle cove off St. Thomas, and tours are sold under the same name.

The bow of a boat heading toward two green islands, one with a palm-lined beach, across bright turquoise water
A boat bow and two green islands, the view that makes the two names easy to mix up.

Booking choice: The Turtle Cove catamaran snorkel, from $119 per person. Check dates Compare the options below

Search for Buck Island tours and you get two places mixed together. One is a national monument off St. Croix with a famous snorkel trail. The other is a small wildlife refuge south of St. Thomas, which boats sell as Little Buck Island or Turtle Cove. They are different islands, run by different agencies.

Facts come from the National Park Service, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the Viator listings, checked on 19 November 2026. For fares see the prices guide.

The quick answer

Every Buck Island snorkel on this site goes to the refuge off St. Thomas, such as the Turtle Cove catamaran at $119. The national monument off St. Croix is visited by NPS-authorised boats booked outside Viator.

Towels laid out on a white sand beach under leaning palm trees beside turquoise water
A palm beach with towels, the kind of shore the monument's west beach offers.

Which Buck Island is which?

Buck Island Reef National Monument is off St. Croix. The Buck Island that St. Thomas boats visit is a separate national wildlife refuge, about 2 miles south of St. Thomas.

The table sets the two side by side.

Monument, off St. CroixRefuge, off St. Thomas
Run byNational Park ServiceU.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Known forMarked underwater snorkel trail, elkhorn coralTurtle Cove, green turtles over seagrass
Can you land?Yes, at the west beach, 7:00 to 17:00Closed to public access, per the agency
Reached byNPS-authorised boats from ChristianstedTurtle sails from St. Thomas
On Viator here?NoYes

Which Buck Island do the Viator tours visit?

The turtle sails go to the St. Thomas one. The VI Cat, Cruz Bay Watersports and Fury head for Turtle Cove, and the semi-private trip adds Honeymoon Beach.

The flagship listing is titled for the Buck Island wildlife refuge. The semi-private listing names Buck Island and Honeymoon Beach, and guests describe two islands. The St. Croix listings, like the Frederiksted turtle snorkel and the sunset sail, are not Buck Island tours.

A turquoise cove under green hills, with a sailboat at its edge
A turquoise cove on the St. Thomas side, close to where the turtle sails stop.

About three hours on a catamaran to Turtle Cove off St. Thomas, with drinks, snacks and gear.

Check dates for the Turtle Cove catamaran snorkel

Does Viator sell a trip to Buck Island Reef National Monument?

Not here. None of the listings on this site goes to the monument, and the boats sold under the Buck Island name on Viator sail from St. Thomas.

That is the main trap. A traveler who has read about the underwater trail books a Buck Island tour and lands at the other island, which is a good snorkel but a different one. Check the departure point on any listing: Frenchman's Cove, the Westin, Yacht Haven Grande and Havensight are all on St. Thomas.

How do you book the monument trip?

Through an NPS-authorised operator. The NPS things-to-know page says to book with an authorised concessionaire, and that hiring any other vessel is not permitted.

The NPS basic information page lists the current boats, which leave from the Christiansted waterfront or Green Cay Marina. Half-day and full-day trips are common, and a half day runs about four hours door to door per the Go to St. Croix day-trip blog. Book direct with the operator, and ask what is included.

Sailboats on dark blue water with hills and a town in the distance
A wide harbor view, the kind of departure scene on both islands.

Can you land on either island?

On the monument, yes, at the west beach during daylight. On the St. Thomas refuge, no: the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service refuge page says it is closed to public access.

On the St. Thomas side boats anchor offshore, and snorkelers swim from the boat. The Recreation.gov page describes the surrounding water as a place for snorkeling, which does not match the agency's page on the island itself, so sources differ. What the listings sell is a snorkel in the cove, not a beach day, and your operator will tell you the exact stop.

A boat rail with an orange lifebuoy and a green island beyond a grey sea
A boat rail and a green island on the horizon.

Which one should you choose?

Pick the monument for the marked underwater trail and a half or full day. Pick a St. Thomas turtle sail for turtles in a short boat day.

If you are staying on St. Thomas or calling there by ship, the realistic choice is a turtle sail such as Fury or the flagship catamaran. If you are on St. Croix and want the trail, the monument is the answer. If you are on St. Croix and want turtles for less time and money, the Frederiksted snorkel is a different, smaller product.

Frederiksted Sea Turtle Snorkel

A short shore snorkel off Frederiksted, St. Croix, with gear and a guide. Not a Buck Island trip.

★ 4.5 37 reviews · 1 hour 15 minutes · from $59

Explore the Frederiksted turtle snorkel

Can you do both Buck Islands on one trip?

Only with two separate days. They are on different islands of the territory, with the sea between them.

The monument trips leave from St. Croix and the turtle sails from St. Thomas, so there is no single tour that links them. Most visitors do one and skip the other. Decide by which island you are sleeping on.

How do you avoid booking the wrong one?

Read the departure point, then the title, then the reviews. A St. Thomas address means the St. Thomas refuge.

Listings from Frenchman's Cove, the Westin at Frenchman's Reef, Yacht Haven Grande and the Havensight pier are on St. Thomas. Departures from Christiansted and Green Cay are on St. Croix. A listing on St. Croix named for turtles, like the ecotour, is a shore snorkel, so read it twice before you assume it is a boat day.

A white catamaran moored in a bay beside a wooded shore and a small beach
A catamaran moored beside a wooded shore.

Frequently asked questions

Are there two Buck Islands in the Virgin Islands?

Yes. A national monument off St. Croix and a national wildlife refuge, often sold as Little Buck Island, south of St. Thomas.

Which Buck Island do turtle tours from St. Thomas go to?

The St. Thomas refuge, where boats stop for a snorkel at Turtle Cove. They do not go to the monument off St. Croix.

Can you book Buck Island Reef National Monument on Viator?

Not through any listing on this site. The monument is visited by NPS-authorised boats from Christiansted, booked with the operator.

Can you land on Buck Island off St. Thomas?

No. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service says the refuge is closed to public access, so tours snorkel from the boat.

Ready to book

Choose your Buck Island tour

Every option here can be cancelled for a full refund; the deadline is on each listing. Prices are from-prices in USD and move with the season.

Turtle Cove Catamaran Snorkel

Turtle Cove Catamaran Snorkel

★ 4.8 2,331 reviews · About 3 hours

  • A catamaran trip to Turtle Cove at the St. Thomas Buck Island, not the St. Croix national monument
  • Snorkel mask, snorkel, vest and fins, plus a local guide
  • Snacks and unlimited drinks, with alcohol served after the in-water activities
From$119per personCheck dates
Semi-Private Buck Island Snorkel

Semi-Private Buck Island Snorkel

★ 4.7 737 reviews · About 4 hours

  • A small boat from Havensight Cruise Pier, with two stops
  • Snorkel gear, soda, bottled water and alcoholic drinks
  • Time at Honeymoon Beach, where reviewers say you swim ashore
From$160per personCheck dates
Frederiksted Sea Turtle Snorkel

Frederiksted Sea Turtle Snorkel

★ 4.5 37 reviews · 1 hour 15 minutes

  • Use of snorkeling equipment
  • A shore entry reviewers place right outside the cruise port
  • Reviewers report turtles, rays, conch and tarpon, and one wanted more turtles
From$59per personCheck dates

Plan your date before you go

About three hours on a catamaran to Turtle Cove off St. Thomas, with snacks, drinks, snorkel gear and a vest. Full refund up to 24 hours before.

Check dates for the Turtle Cove catamaran snorkel